Puke Green or Reptile Green?

All greens are not created equal.  Or are they?

Here’s the Puke Green color we discussed with the neighbors:

Here’s the Reptile Green our room was painted in when we first moved in.  The effect was achieved by applying a light green over a dark green with—wait for it!—a sponge:

The question is: Which is uglier? 

In small doses I think the Puke Green could work as an accent color; for example as pillows, picture frames or an ashtray in a non-smoking house.  

Meanwhile, Reptile Green--sponged on--never works.  Therefore I've decided: our formerly Reptile Green color is uglier!

What do you think?